New Atlas Intel poll showing Democrats with a nine-point lead has sparked debate over its statistical reliability as experts question sample size and methodology.
At a Glance
- Atlas Intel poll claims Democrats lead by nine points on the generic ballot while Trump holds 55% approval
- Rasmussen pollster Mark Mitchell questions the poll’s reliability due to small sample size concerns
- Mitchell compares it to previously inaccurate Selzer poll that erroneously showed Harris leading Trump in Iowa
- NBC News polling shows Trump’s approval at 47% with mixed results on specific policy areas
- Conflicting polls show deep political divisions as America moves into the 2026 midterm election cycle
Poll Results Spark Controversy
A new survey from Atlas Intel has generated significant attention in political circles with findings that place Democrats nine points ahead in the generic congressional ballot while simultaneously showing President Donald Trump with a 55% approval rating. The poll has been met with enthusiasm from liberal commentators who view it as evidence of declining Republican fortunes, but polling experts have raised serious questions about its methodology and reliability. The contradictory nature of the results – showing both high presidential approval and poor party performance – has fueled skepticism about the poll’s accuracy.
DEMOCRATS SLIDE FURTHER—ONLY 1 IN 3 FEEL HOPEFUL ABOUT PARTY’S FUTURE
A new AP/NORC poll just confirmed it—Democratic optimism is cratering.
Only 35% of Democrats feel positive about the party’s future, down from 57% last July.
Internal divides, Biden’s exit, and frustration… https://t.co/VxUVmXONEz pic.twitter.com/66WpnC3vZM
— Mario Nawfal (@MarioNawfal) May 16, 2025
Mark Mitchell from Rasmussen Reports has emerged as a prominent critic of the Atlas Intel findings. Mitchell specifically pointed to concerns about the poll’s sample size, suggesting it lacks statistical credibility. “With the sample sizes involved, the Atlas poll is less statistically believable than the Selzer Iowa poll,” Mitchell stated, referencing a previous controversial poll that incorrectly showed Kamala Harris leading Trump in Iowa during the 2024 campaign.
Conflicting Polling Landscape
The Atlas Intel poll stands in contrast to other major surveys that present a more nuanced view of the political landscape. NBC News polling shows Trump’s approval rating at 47%, matching his best-ever mark, though 51% disapprove of his performance. The NBC survey reveals a deeply divided electorate with voters holding mixed views across various policy areas. While Trump receives positive marks on immigration, he faces challenges on economic issues with only 18% of voters rating the economy as “excellent” or “good.”
“While this survey shows a mixed result for Donald Trump, Democrats are the ones in the wilderness right now,” said Jeff Horwitt, whose firm conducted the NBC News poll.
The conflicting poll results highlight the challenges of accurately measuring public opinion in today’s polarized political environment. Trump’s own assessment of his electoral victory – “I won on the border and I won on groceries” – reflects his focus on immigration and economic issues, though polls suggest Americans remain divided on his handling of these matters. Within the Republican Party, Trump enjoys robust support, creating a significant partisan gap in approval ratings.
Implications for 2026 Midterms
The debate over polling accuracy comes at a critical time as both parties begin positioning for the 2026 midterm elections. The NBC News poll indicates voters are split on which party should control Congress after the midterms, with neither Republicans nor Democrats holding a decisive advantage. The Democratic Party continues to face challenges with low popularity ratings and internal divisions following their 2024 losses, while Republicans must navigate public skepticism about their economic policies.
“Basically Atlas with their latest poll: ‘I, for one, welcome our socialist overlords..”, Mitchell remarked sarcastically about the Atlas Intel findings, suggesting the poll may be creating a misleading narrative about Republican unpopularity.
Political analysts caution against reading too much into any poll, particularly those with methodological questions. Historical polling data show that presidential approval ratings and generic ballot tests can fluctuate significantly in the early years of an administration. The conflicting narratives presented by different surveys underscore the importance of focusing on polling averages rather than individual results that may represent statistical outliers.
Economic Concerns Remain Central
Regardless of which poll Americans trust, economic concerns remain at the forefront of voter priorities. The NBC News survey reveals that most Americans believe their family income is falling behind the cost of living, with only 18% rating economic conditions positively. This presents both challenges and opportunities for President Trump as he navigates his second term. Markets have shown sensitivity to proposed tariff policies, while businesses express uncertainty about the administration’s economic focus.
“For the strength of the Republican and Trump base has maintained a very competitive election,” noted Bill McInturff, referring to the continued strong support Trump receives from his core voters despite mixed overall approval ratings.
As the debate over polling methodology continues, voters’ economic experiences will likely play a more significant role than any survey in determining the political landscape heading into the 2026 midterm elections. Polling experts recommend focusing on trends across multiple surveys rather than headline-grabbing results from any single poll, particularly those with questionable methodology or sample sizes that fail to meet rigorous statistical standards.
