Governor’s Pen vs Constitution – 382 Cases Hang

empty prison corridor with barred cells
Photo: rawf8 / Shutterstock

Governor Gavin Newsom just commuted all 548 death sentences in California, and now 30 county prosecutors and grieving families are hauling him before the state’s highest court to stop it.

Story Snapshot

  • Newsom announced on November 5 that he commuted every California death sentence to life without parole.
  • District attorneys from 30 counties sued, saying victims never got a chance to speak before the mass action.
  • About 382 of the 548 cases legally need California Supreme Court approval first because the prisoners had multiple felony convictions.
  • Victims’ families, including one whose daughter was murdered in 2008, say Newsom ignored the voters who backed capital punishment.

A Governor Clears Death Row With One Letter

Newsom announced in a November 5 open letter that he was using his “constitutional clemency authority” to commute every California death sentence to life without the possibility of parole. He called it “the most severe punishment I can lawfully impose,” framing the move as the end of a death penalty fight he’s waged for nearly three decades. The decision instantly became the largest mass commutation in American history, covering 548 condemned killers.

Newsom had already frozen executions back in 2019 with a moratorium, so this was not a sudden reversal. It was the long-promised next step for a governor who has openly opposed the death penalty his entire career. But promising something and legally pulling it off are two different things, and that gap is exactly where this story gets messy.

The Constitution Says Not So Fast

California’s Constitution does give governors power to commute sentences after conviction. But it also contains a built-in roadblock: anyone “twice convicted of a felony” cannot be commuted unless the California Supreme Court recommends it, with at least four justices agreeing. Reporting tied to the governor’s own office confirms 382 of the 548 prisoners fall into that category, meaning Newsom’s “blanket” commutation is not actually finished for most of them.

That leaves only 166 cases Newsom could lawfully commute on his own, without the court’s sign-off. For the other 382, nothing is final unless four Supreme Court justices agree and Newsom then signs individual orders for each one. Right now, the record shows an announced plan, not a completed legal act covering every killer on death row.

Prosecutors And Victims Say They Were Shut Out

District attorneys from 30 counties filed a lawsuit arguing Newsom acted unlawfully by denying victims the “opportunity to be heard” before the mass commutation. Los Angeles County District Attorney Nathan Hochman said his office personally reviewed more than 50 death-penalty cases and talked directly with victims’ families before any decision, something Newsom’s blanket approach skipped entirely. He called the move an action that “sidelines victims’ families and disregards the will of California voters, juries and judges”.

The Criminal Justice Legal Foundation, led by Anne Marie Schubert, says Newsom’s office never even contacted the district attorneys who prosecuted these 548 cases before going public. Schubert argues many families learned about freeing their loved ones’ killers from the news, not from the prosecutors who were supposed to protect their rights. Faye Jenkins, whose daughter and son-in-law were murdered in 2008, put it simply: “We voted for this.”

A National Pattern, But An Unusual Scale

Mass death-row commutations aren’t new. Illinois Governor George Ryan cleared 167 death sentences in 2003 over wrongful-conviction fears, and President Biden commuted 37 of 40 federal death sentences in 2024. Since 1976, roughly a dozen governors have issued blanket clemency, far outnumbering individualized grants. Newsom’s action fits that pattern in form but dwarfs it in size, covering more condemned prisoners at once than almost any governor before him.

President Trump has already weighed in publicly against the decision, calling it a disaster for justice and warning that some of the spared inmates are violent repeat offenders. The California District Attorneys Association says the decision erases “hundreds of individual sentencing decisions” reached after years of trials and appeals, replacing them with a single stroke of a pen that makes no distinction between the worst killers and lesser offenders.

What Happens Next

The California Supreme Court must now decide whether to halt the commutations while it reviews the 382 contested cases, and whether Newsom’s office followed required notice rules for victims and prosecutors. Until the justices rule, the fate of hundreds of death sentences stays unsettled, caught between a governor’s pen and a Constitution that was written to keep executive power from moving unchecked.

Sources:

nypost.com, gov.ca.gov, leginfo.legislature.ca.gov, cnn.com, sacbee.com, da.lacounty.gov, bbc.com